Every Elmore Leonard Western Story
The Delacorte collection cherry-picked the western stories; HarperCollins editor Marjorie Braman published them all in 2004.
In 2003, I lobbied Majorie Braman, Dutch’s new editor at HarperCollins, to publish all of Elmore Leonard western stories. Marjorie, who Dutch and I got along great with, green lit the book and appointed me Collections Editor.
This was not the first Elmore Leonard western story collection. In 1998, Delacorte published a collection called Tonto Woman and Other Western Stories. Devoted Elmore Leonard fan, Joel Lyczak, who suggested a western collection to Dutch as far back as the 80s, assembled thirty stories, but only nineteen were included in the Tonto Woman collection.
So we gave Marjorie the 30 stories, but, as I wrote in a previous post, we had a sneaking suspicion there was another story lurking out there. Joel, had found evidence of a story we missed. Among the Elmore Leonard papers at the University of Detroit Library he found a missing title on an index card: Fury at Four Turnings. Read how I successfully tracked that story down.
There are a few extras in the Complete Westerns. I built a map of all the places the stories were set in and around southern Arizona. I also included the original titles for many of the stories. See the map and title list below.
Here is my introduction to The Complete Westerns Stories of Elmore Leonard
Conversation with Elmore Leonard
ELMORE JOHN LEONARD, Jr., started his life of writing in the fifth grade, when as a student at Blessed Sacrament Grade School in Detroit, he was inspired by a Detroit Times serialization of All Quiet on the Western Front, wrote a play, and staged it at school, the classroom desks serving as no manʼs land.
He did not write again until his college years at the University of Detroit, where he majored in English. He wrote a few experimental short stories while spending most of his free time reading and going to the movies.
“I was discovering who I liked to read,” he said. “I wasnʼt reading for story, I was reading for style.”
Sometime shortly after college Elmore decided he wanted to be a writer.
“I looked for a genre where I could learn how to write and be selling at the same time,” he recalls. “I chose Westerns because I liked Western movies. From the time I was a kid I liked them. Movies like The Plainsman with Gary Cooper in 1936 up through My Darling Clementine and Red River in the late forties.”
There was a surge of interest in Western stories in the early fifties, Elmore notes,
“from Saturday Evening Post and Colliers down through Argosy, Adventure, Blue Book, and probably at least a dozen pulp magazines, the better ones like Dime Western and Zane Grey Magazine paying two cents a word.”
His first attempt at writing a Western was not a success.
“I wrote about a gunsmith that made a certain kind of gun. I have no idea now what the story was about when I sent it to a pulp magazine and it was rejected. I decided Iʼd better do some research. I read On the Border with Crook, The Truth about Geronimo, The Look of the West, and Western Words, and I subscribed to Arizona Highways. It had stories about guns—I insisted on authentic guns in my stories—stagecoach lines, specific looks at different little facets of the West, plus all the four-color shots that I could use for my descriptions, things I could put in and sound like I knew what I was talking about.”
He distilled all this valuable detail into a ledger book, which became a constant reference for his story writing throughout the decade.
Properly armed with a sense of the West, he wrote his first Western, “Tizwin”, the Apache name for corn beer. It didnʼt sell immediately.
“The editor at Argosy passed it on to one of their pulp magazines at Popular Publications,” Elmore remembers, “and they bought it.”
And changed the title to “Red Hell Hits Canyon Diablo.”
“The Argosy editor said, ʻIf you have anything else about this period, weʼd like to read it.ʼ So I sat down and wrote ʻTrail of the Apache,ʼ which was the first one that was published.”
A growing family and a full-time job as a copywriter on the Chevrolet account at Campbell-Ewald Advertising in Detroit did not give Elmore a lot of time to write.
“I realized that I was going to have to get up at five in the morning if I wanted to write fiction. It took a while, the alarm would go off and Iʼd roll over. Finally I started to get up and go into the living room and sit at the coffee table with a yellow pad and try to write two pages. I made a rule that I had to get something down on paper before I could put the water on for the coffee. Know where youʼre going and then put the water on. That seemed to work because I did it for most of the fifties.”
Heʼd also get a little writing done at the agency.
“Iʼd put my arm in the drawer and have the tablet in there and Iʼd just start writing and if somebody came in Iʼd stop writing and close the drawer.”
Elmore began to focus on a particular area of the West for his stories.
“I liked Arizona and New Mexico,” he said. “I didnʼt care that much for the High Plains Indians, I liked the Apaches because of their reputation as raiders and the way they dressed, with a headband and high moccasins up to their knees. I also liked their involvement with things Mexican and their use of Spanish names and words.”
The Complete Western Stories begins with Elmoreʼs first five shorts: Apache and cavalry stories set in Arizona in the 1870s and ʼ80s.
“I was disappointed by rejections from the better-paying magazines, The Saturday Evening Post and Colliers,” Elmore says. “They felt my stories were too relentless and lacked lighter moments or comic relief. But I continued to write what pleased me while trying to improve my style.”
The next direction for Elmoreʼs writing was obvious: write a Western novel. The result was The Bounty Hunters (1953), the prototype for many an Elmore Leonard Western. Take the most dangerous Apache, the wisest scout, and the greediest outlaw, put them all together in the desert sun, and see who wins.
As he spun out novels and short stories from five to seven in the morning, Hollywood came calling and bought a Dime Western story, “Three-Ten to Yuma,” and from Argosy, “The Captives,” filmed as The Tall T. Elmore was excited but in both cases
“I saw how easily Hollywood could screw up a simple story.”
Both films, released in 1957, are now regarded as minor classics.
Elmore reached his goal as a Western writer in April of 1956, when The Saturday Evening Post published his story “Moment of Vengeance.” In less than five years he had entered the pantheon of Western writers. But the Western was on its way out.
“Television killed the Western,” Elmore says. “The pulps were mostly gone by then too, the market was drying up.”
In 1960, Elmore took his profit sharing from Campbell-Ewald— $11,500—with the intention of becoming a full-time writer. He had put his ten years in.
“The money would have lasted six months, and in that time I could write a book and sell it.”
Instead, the family bought a house and he wrote freelance advertising copy and educational films to pay the bills until the movie version of his novel Hombre was bought by a studio in 1966, and he finally had the money to write his first non-Western novel, The Big Bounce.
But he wasnʼt through with the Westerns by any means. He had yet to write what many consider to be his masterpiece.
Just before his five-year fiction-writing hiatus, in 1961, he wrote a story for Roundup, a Western Writers of America anthology, called “Only Good Ones,” the story of Bob Valdez, soon to be the classic Elmore Leonard hero who is misjudged by the antagonist,
“the bad guys realizing too late theyʼll be lucky to get out of this alive.”
Six years later, in search of an idea for a novel he could sell to the movies, Elmore picked up “Only Good Ones” and, in seven weeks, expanded it into Valdez Is Coming (1970) which was brought to the big screen with Burt Lancaster three years later.
“Look what I got away with,” Elmore says. “In the final scene of Valdez there is no shootout, not even in the film version. Writing this one I found that I could loosen up, concentrate on bringing the characters to life with recognizable traits, and ignore some of the conventions found in most Western stories.”
The Complete Western Stories of Elmore Leonard charts the evolution of Elmoreʼs style and particular sound from the very beginning of his writing career. In five years, between 1951 and 1956, he wrote twenty-seven of the thirty stories in this volume. He carved out his turf in the Arizona and New Mexico Territories, from Bisbee to Contention, from Yuma Territorial Prison to the Jicarilla Apache Sub agency in Puerco, creating dozens of memorable characters: good, bad, and really bad. (Those are the ones we like the most.)
Elmore Leonard wrote a total of eight Western novels before, during, and after his Complete Western Stories; he even wrote a few Western stories contained herein, after he began writing contemporary crime novels (“The Tonto Woman” and “ʻHurrah for Captain Early!ʼ”). Over time, the suffocating heat and alkali dust of the Arizona desert gave way to the mean streets of Detroit and the subtropical weirdness of South Florida.
But Elmore will be the first to tell you, theyʼre all derived from what he learned writing these Western stories; he just changed the setting and the century.
Gregg Sutter, Los Angeles, 2004
Original Elmore Leonard Western Story Names
There are some classic titles below that were not used — editors know best, I guess, but how could they not love The Hanging of Bobby Valdez?
Trail of the Apache - Original Title: Apache Agent, Argosy, December 1951
Apache Medicine - Original Title: Medicine, Dime Western Magazine, May 1952
You Never See Apaches… - Original Title: 8 Days from Willcox, Dime Western Magazine, September 1952
Red Hell Hits Canyon Diablo - Original Title: Tizwin, 10-Story Western, October 1952
The Colonel’s Lady - Original Title: Road to Inspiration, Zane Grey’s Western, November 1952
Law of the Hunted One - Original Title: Outlaw Pass, Western Story Magazine, December 1952
The Rustlers - Original Title: Along the Pecos, Zane Grey Western, February 1953
The Big Hunt - Original Title: Matt Gordon’s Boy, Western Story Magazine, April 1953
The Last Shot - Original Title: A Matter of Duty
Blood Money - Original Title: Rich Miller’s Hand, Western Story Magazine, October 1953
Trouble at Rindo’s Station - Original Title: Rindo’s Station, Argosy, October 1953
Saint with a Six-Gun - Original Title: The Hanging of Bobby Valdez, Argosy, October 1954
The Captives - Film Title: The Tall T, Argosy, February 1955
The Rancher’s Lady - Original Title: The Woman from Tascosa, Western Magazine, September 1955
Jugged - Original Title: The Boy from Dos Cabezas, Western Magazine, December 1955
Moment of Vengeance - Original Title: The Waiting Man, Saturday Evening Post, April 21, 1956
Man with the Iron Arm - Original Title: The One-Armed Man, Complete Western Book, September 1956
The Nagual - Original Title: The Accident at John Stands, Two Gun Western, November 1956
The Kid - Original Title: The Gift of Regalo, Western Short Stories, December 1956
The Treasure of Mungos Landing - Original Title: Fury at Four Turnings, True Adventures, 1958